Savor Scout › What to eat › Where to eat with picky eaters
Where to eat with picky eaters
The usual solution is to give up and go somewhere with a menu so broad it is good at nothing. That works, in the sense that everyone eats, and it is also why the same group has been to the same three places for two years.
It helps enormously to know which kind of picky you are dealing with, because they need opposite solutions. Texture-averse eaters can usually handle bold flavours as long as nothing is slimy, mushy, or unexpectedly cold. Flavour-averse eaters want mild, and will eat almost any texture. Novelty-averse eaters are fine with both and simply will not order something they cannot picture.
Once you know which one it is, the target changes. For a novelty-averse eater, a specialised restaurant with one recognisable dish is much better than a broad menu — a ramen shop has exactly one thing on it and that thing is noodles in soup, which is picturable. For a texture-averse eater, a grill is safer than a curry house, regardless of how broad either menu is.
The move that almost always works, across all three: somewhere that cooks one protein well and lets you choose the surroundings. Grilled meat and rice, a taqueria, a rotisserie, a pizza place with plain on the menu. Plainness available on request beats plainness as the house style.
What to look for:
- A plain version of the house dish — Not a kids' menu. A place where the signature thing can be ordered without the sauce is far more use than a place with chicken fingers in a corner of the menu.
- Build-your-own anything — Burritos, poke, pizza, grain bowls, banh mi. The picky eater constructs something safe and everyone else constructs something interesting, from the same kitchen.
- Sides that are a meal — Somewhere with genuinely good bread, rice, fries or grilled vegetables gives a fallback that is not humiliating to order.
- Sauce on the side as a normal request — A kitchen that is relaxed about modifications is worth more than a kitchen with a wider menu. Reviews mentioning accommodating staff are a real signal here.
- One dish everyone has heard of — Not because it is the best thing there, but because its presence lowers the stakes enough for everyone else to order adventurously.
Try this search
Savor Scout takes a sentence rather than a category, so the criteria above can go straight into the box. For this, something like “grilled meat and rice, simple menu, sauces on the side” works — it reads menus and reviews for those specific things and comes back with one place and the reasons it picked it.
Search “grilled meat and rice, simple menu, sauces on the side” →
What usually goes wrong
Tasting menus, shared-plates-only restaurants, and anywhere the entire menu is one strong flavour profile. Also avoid making it a discussion at the table — deciding in advance is a kindness to the picky eater, who generally knows they are the constraint and does not enjoy it.
If you're deciding as a group
If the group is big enough that there is more than one picky eater, stop negotiating and use a room. Each person gets a veto, which lets someone remove the place they genuinely cannot eat at without having to explain themselves to five people.
What to eat
Worth considering here: pizza, tacos, fried chicken, sandwiches, barbecue.
Related
- Where to eat with a big group
- Where to eat with a toddler
- Where to eat when half the group is vegetarian